Skip to main content
Solved

Cost after by-product are removed

  • Nov 19, 2026 11:58 AM UTC
  • 2 replies
  • 24 views

Forum|alt.badge.img+9
  • Sidekick (Partner)

Hi

We are running a test with two shop orders. The shop orders are identical, beside one is having a byproduct.

The by-product is a small cap first added to the production process and then later removed and put back on stock for reuse.

It would be logical, if the finished product, where the caps are removed are cheaper, than the version, where the cap remains on the finished product. However, that is not the case. The finished product with the byproduct increase its value when recalculated.

 

Shop order with no By product:

 

 

Shop order with By product

 

 

Can somebody explain the mathematic of his?

If possible, please also explain why the Standard accumulated cost changes, and not the Estimated Accumulated Cost.

Normally the Estimated Cost are coming from the Order,

 

Regards

Brian

Best answer by dameenda

Hi, sed on this “The by-product is a small cap first added to the production process and then later removed and put back on stock for reuse.”

The cap supposed to be a Not consumed part in the Product Structure, also when not consumed are used, there is a cost parameter for the Site “Include Not Consumed”  if is not checked, the cost of that part is not considered for Part Cost Calculations.

 

This standard cost is usually the cost of the part minus the cost of the by Product

Since the by products being produced in a production cost carries a financial value, its assumed that the cost for main product = total cost - Cost of the by product

But if you check the “Use by Product Cost Distribution” in the Shop Order, then we can enter percentages from the Cost of main part that should go in to the By Product.

However the definition is the by product is something we produce with the main product, so the cap mentioned in the example is not a byproduct, it is an expensed part, which can be added in the material list as a Nor Consumed Item, You need to enable allow as Not Consumed in the Part page to use a particular par as a Not Consumed part in a BO.

View original

2 replies

Forum|alt.badge.img+11
  • Hero (Employee)
  • Answer
  • Nov 19, 2026 1:57 PM UTC

Hi, sed on this “The by-product is a small cap first added to the production process and then later removed and put back on stock for reuse.”

The cap supposed to be a Not consumed part in the Product Structure, also when not consumed are used, there is a cost parameter for the Site “Include Not Consumed”  if is not checked, the cost of that part is not considered for Part Cost Calculations.

 

This standard cost is usually the cost of the part minus the cost of the by Product

Since the by products being produced in a production cost carries a financial value, its assumed that the cost for main product = total cost - Cost of the by product

But if you check the “Use by Product Cost Distribution” in the Shop Order, then we can enter percentages from the Cost of main part that should go in to the By Product.

However the definition is the by product is something we produce with the main product, so the cap mentioned in the example is not a byproduct, it is an expensed part, which can be added in the material list as a Nor Consumed Item, You need to enable allow as Not Consumed in the Part page to use a particular par as a Not Consumed part in a BO.


Forum|alt.badge.img+9
  • Author
  • Sidekick (Partner)
  • Nov 20, 2026 10:39 AM UTC

Hi, sed on this “The by-product is a small cap first added to the production process and then later removed and put back on stock for reuse.”

The cap supposed to be a Not consumed part in the Product Structure, also when not consumed are used, there is a cost parameter for the Site “Include Not Consumed”  if is not checked, the cost of that part is not considered for Part Cost Calculations.

 

This standard cost is usually the cost of the part minus the cost of the by Product

Since the by products being produced in a production cost carries a financial value, its assumed that the cost for main product = total cost - Cost of the by product

But if you check the “Use by Product Cost Distribution” in the Shop Order, then we can enter percentages from the Cost of main part that should go in to the By Product.

However the definition is the by product is something we produce with the main product, so the cap mentioned in the example is not a byproduct, it is an expensed part, which can be added in the material list as a Nor Consumed Item, You need to enable allow as Not Consumed in the Part page to use a particular par as a Not Consumed part in a BO.

Dameenda, Thanks for your quick reply.

The small cap is added at an earlier stage in the production and not on this specific Shop Order/Structure.  However, Practically it is removed during the manufacturing of this structure.

The “Not consumed” idea is good, but does not work in this case. We found a way forward using the By Product Cost Distribution. The problem is solved